For hundreds of years, sci-fi writers
have imagined weapons
that might use energy waves or pulses to knock out, knock down, or otherwise
disable enemies--without necessarily killing them. And for a good 40 years
the U.S. military has quietly been pursuing weapons of this sort. Much of
this work is still secret, and it has yet to produce a usable "nonlethal"
weapon. But now that the cold war has ended and the United States is engaged
in more humanitarian and peacekeeping missions, the search for weapons that
could incapacitate people without inflicting lethal injuries has intensified.
The Pentagon's quest for nonlethal arms is amazing. But is it smart?
By Douglas Pasternak
Tucked away in the corner of a drab industrial park in Huntington Beach,
Calif., is a windowless, nondescript building. Inside, under extremely tight
security, engineers and scientists are working on devices whose ordinary
appearance masks the oddity of their function. One is cone shaped, about the
size of a fire hydrant. Another is a 3-foot-long metal tube, mounted on a
tripod, with some black boxes at the operator's end. These are the newest
weapons of war.
For hundreds of years, sci-fi writers have imagined weapons
that might use energy waves or pulses to knock out, knock down, or otherwise
disable enemies--without necessarily killing them. And for a good 40 years
the U.S. military has quietly been pursuing weapons of this sort. Much of
this work is still secret, and it has yet to produce a usable "nonlethal"
weapon. But now that the cold war has ended and the United States is engaged
in more humanitarian and peacekeeping missions, the search for weapons that
could incapacitate people without inflicting lethal injuries has
intensified. Police, too, are keenly interested. Scores of new contracts
have been let, and scientists, aided by government research on the
"bioeffects" of beamed energy, are searching the electromagnetic and sonic
spectrums for wavelengths that can affect human behavior. Recent
advancements in miniaturized electronics, power generation, and beam aiming
may finally have put such pulse and beam weapons on the cusp of
practicality, some experts say.
Weapons already exist that use lasers, which
can temporarily or permanently blind enemy soldiers. So-called acoustic or
sonic weapons, like the ones in the aforementioned lab, can vibrate the
insides of humans to stun them, nauseate them, or even "liquefy their bowels
and reduce them to quivering diarrheic messes," according to a Pentagon
briefing. Prototypes of such weapons were recently considered for tryout
when U.S. troops intervened in Somalia. Other, stranger effects also have
been explored, such as using electromagnetic waves to put human targets to
sleep or to heat them up, on the microwave-oven principle.
Scientists are
also trying to make a sonic cannon that throws a shock wave with enough
force to knock down a man.
While this and similar weapons may seem
far-fetched, scientists say they are natural successors to projects already
underway--beams that disable the electronic systems of aircraft, computers,
or missiles, for instance. "Once you are into these antimateriel weapons, it
is a short jump to antipersonnel weapons," says Louis Slesin, editor of the
trade journal Microwave News. That's because the human body is essentially
an electrochemical system, and devices that disrupt the electrical impulses
of the nervous system can affect behavior and body functions. But these
programs--particularly those involving antipersonnel research--are so well
guarded that details are scarce. "People [in the military] go silent on this
issue," says Slesin, "more than any other issue. People just do not want to
talk about this."
Projects underway
To learn what the Pentagon has been
doing, U.S. News talked to more than 70 experts and scoured biomedical and
engineering journals, contracts, budgets, and research proposals. The effort
to develop exotic weapons is surprising in its range. Scores of projects are
underway, most with funding of several hundred thousand dollars each. One
Air Force lab plans to spend more than $100 million by 2003 to research the
"bioeffects" of such weaponry.
The benefits of bloodless battles for
soldiers and law enforcement are obvious. But the search for new
weapons--cloaked as they are in secrecy--faces hurdles. One is the acute
skepticism of many conventional-weapons experts. "It is interesting
technology but it won't end bloodshed and wars," says Harvey Sapolsky,
director of the Security Studies Program at MIT. Says Charles Bernard, a
former Navy weapons-research director: "I have yet to see one of these ray
gun things that actually works." And if they do work, other problems arise:
Some so-called nonlethal weapons could end up killing rather than just
disabling victims if used at the wrong range. Others may easily be thwarted
by shielding.
Sterner warnings come from ethicists. Years ago the world
drafted conventions and treaties to attempt to set rules for the use of
bullets and bombs in war. But no treaties govern the use of unconventional
weapons. And no one knows what will happen to people exposed to them over
the long term.
Moreover, medical researchers worry that their work on such
things as the use of electromagnetic waves to stimulate hearing in the deaf
or to halt seizures in epileptics might be used to develop weaponry. In
fact, the military routinely has approached the National Institutes of
Health for research information. "DARPA [Defense Advanced Research Projects
Agency] has come to us every few years to see if there are ways to
incapacitate the central nervous system remotely," Dr. F. Terry Hambrecht,
head of the Neural Prosthesis Program at NIH, told U.S. News. "But nothing
has ever come of it," he said. "That is too science fiction and
far-fetched." Still, the Pentagon plans to conduct human testing with lasers
and acoustics in the future, says Charles Swett, an assistant for Special
Operations and Low-Intensity Conflict. Swett insists that the testing will
be constrained and highly ethical. It may not be far off. The U.S. Air Force
expects to have microwave weapons by the year 2015 and other nonlethal
weaponry sooner. "When that does happen," warns Steven Metz, professor of
national security affairs at the U.S. Army War College, "I think there will
be a public uproar. We need an open debate on them now."
Laser ethics
What happened with U.S. forces in Somalia foreshadows the
impending ethical dilemmas. In early 1995, some U.S. marines were supplied
with so-called dazzling lasers. The idea was to inflict as little harm as
possible if Somalis turned hostile. But the marines' commander then decided
that the lasers should be "de-tuned" to prevent the chance of their blinding
citizens. With their intensity thus diminished, they could be used only for
designating or illuminating targets.
On March 1, 1995, commandos of U.S.
Navy SEAL Team 5 were positioned at the south end of Mogadishu airport. At 7
a.m., a technician from the Air Force's Phillips Laboratory, developer of
the lasers, used one to illuminate a Somali man armed with a
rocket-propelled grenade. A SEAL sniper shot and killed the Somali. There
was no question the Somali was aiming at the SEALs. But the decision not to
use the laser to dazzle or temporarily blind the man irks some of the
nonlethal-team members. "We were not allowed to disable these guys because
that was considered inhumane," said one. "Putting a bullet in their head is
somehow more humane?"
Despite such arguments, the International Red Cross
and Human Rights Watch have since led a fight against antipersonnel lasers.
In the fall of 1995, the United States signed a treaty that prohibits the
development of lasers designed "to cause permanent blindness." Still, laser
weapons are known to have been developed by the Russians, and proliferation
is a big concern. Also, the treaty does not forbid dazzling or "glare"
lasers, whose effects are temporary. U.S. military labs are continuing work
in this area, and commercial contractors are marketing such lasers to
police.
Acoustic pain
The next debate may well focus on acoustic or sonic weapons.
Benign sonic effects are certainly familiar, ranging from the sonic boom
from an airplane to the ultrasound instrument that "sees" a baby in the
uterus. The military is looking for something less benign--an acoustic
weapon with frequencies tunable all the way up to lethal. Indeed, Huntington
Beach-based Scientific Applications & Research Associates Inc. (SARA) has
built a device that will make internal organs resonate: The effects can run
from discomfort to damage or death. If used to protect an area, its beams
would make intruders increasingly uncomfortable the closer they get. "We
have built several prototypes," says Parviz Parhami, SARA's CEO. Such
acoustic fences, he says, could be deployed today. He estimates that five to
10 years will be needed to develop acoustic rifles and other more exotic
weapons, but adds, "I have heard people as optimistic as one to two years."
The military also envisions acoustic fields being used to control riots or
to clear paths for convoys.
SARA's acoustic devices have already been tested
at the Camp Pendleton Marine Corps Base, near the company's Huntington Beach
office. And they were considered for Somalia. "We asked for acoustics," says
one nonlethal weapons expert who was there. But the Department of Defense
said, "No," since they were still untested. The Pentagon feared they could
have caused permanent injury to pregnant women, the old, or the sick.
Parhami sees acoustics "as just one more tool" for the military and law
enforcement. "Like any tool, I suppose this can be abused," he says. "But
like any tool, it can be used in a humane and ethical way."
Toward the end
of World War II, the Germans were reported to have made a different type of
acoustic device. It looked like a large cannon and sent out a sonic boomlike
shock wave that in theory could have felled a B-17 bomber. In the mid-1940s,
the U.S. Navy created a program called Project Squid to study the German
vortex technology. The results are unknown. But Guy Obolensky, an American
inventor, says he replicated the Nazi device in his laboratory in 1949.
Against hard objects the effect was astounding, he says: It could snap a
board like a twig. Against soft targets like people, it had a different
effect. "I felt like I had been hit by a thick rubber blanket," says
Obolensky, who once stood in its path. The idea seemed to founder for years
until recently, when the military was intrigued by its nonlethal
possibilities. The Army and Navy now have vortex projects underway. The SARA
lab has tested its prototype device at Camp Pendleton, one source says.
Electromagnetic heat
The Soviets were known to have potent blinding lasers.
They were also feared to have developed acoustic and radio-wave weapons. The
1987 issue of Soviet Military Power, a cold war Pentagon publication, warned
that the Soviets might be close to "a prototype short-range tactical RF
[radio frequency] weapon." The Washington Post reported that year that the
Soviets had used such weapons to kill goats at 1 kilometer's range.
The
Pentagon, it turns out, has been pursuing similar devices since the 1960s.
Typical of some of the more exotic proposals are those from Clay Easterly.
Last December, Easterly--who works at the Health Sciences Research Division
of Oak Ridge National Laboratory--briefed the Marine Corps on work he had
conducted for the National Institute of Justice, which does research on
crime control. One of the projects he suggested was an electromagnetic gun
that would "induce epilepticlike seizures." Another was a "thermal gun
[that] would have the operational effect of heating the body to 105 to 107"
degrees Fahrenheit. Such effects would bring on discomfort, fevers, or even
death.
But, unlike the work on blinding lasers and acoustic weapons,
progress here has been slow. The biggest problem is power. High-powered
microwaves intended to heat someone standing 200 yards away to 105 degrees
Fahrenheit may kill someone standing 10 yards away. On the other hand,
electromagnetic fields weaken quickly with distance from the source. And
beams of such energy are difficult to direct to their target. Mission
Research Corp. of Albuquerque, N.M., has used a computer model to study the
ability of microwaves to stimulate the body's peripheral nervous system. "If
sufficient peripheral nerves fire, then the body shuts down to further
stimulus, producing the so-called stun effect," an abstract states. But, it
concludes, "the ranges at which this can be done are only a few meters."
Nonetheless, government laboratories and private contractors are pursuing
numerous similar programs. A 1996 Air Force Scientific Advisory Board report
on future weapons, for instance, includes a classified section on a radio
frequency or "RF Gunship." Other military documents confirm that
radio-frequency antipersonnel weapons programs are underway. And the Air
Force's Armstrong Laboratory at Brooks Air Force Base in Texas is heavily
engaged in such research. According to budget documents, the lab intends to
spend more than $110 million over the next six years "to exploit
less-than-lethal biological effects of electromagnetic radiation for Air
Force security, peacekeeping, and war-fighting operations."
Low-frequency
sleep
From 1980 to 1983, a man named Eldon Byrd ran the Marine Corps
Nonlethal Electromagnetic Weapons project. He conducted most of his research
at the Armed Forces Radiobiology Research Institute in Bethesda, Md. "We
were looking at electrical activity in the brain and how to influence it,"
he says. Byrd, a specialist in medical engineering and bioeffects, funded
small research projects, including a paper on vortex weapons by Obolensky.
He conducted experiments on animals--and even on himself--to see if brain
waves would move into sync with waves impinging on them from the outside.
(He found that they would, but the effect was short lived.)
By using very
low frequency electromagnetic radiation--the waves way below radio
frequencies on the electromagnetic spectrum--he found he could induce the
brain to release behavior-regulating chemicals. "We could put animals into a
stupor," he says, by hitting them with these frequencies. "We got chick
brains--in vitro--to dump 80 percent of the natural opioids in their
brains," Byrd says. He even ran a small project that used magnetic fields to
cause certain brain cells in rats to release histamine. In humans, this
would cause instant flulike symptoms and produce nausea. "These fields were
extremely weak. They were undetectable," says Byrd. "The effects were
nonlethal and reversible. You could disable a person temporarily," Byrd
hypothesizes. "It [would have been] like a stun gun."
Byrd never tested any
of his hardware in the field, and his program, scheduled for four years,
apparently was closed down after two, he says. "The work was really
outstanding," he grumbles. "We would have had a weapon in one year." Byrd
says he was told his work would be unclassified, "unless it works." Because
it worked, he suspects that the program "went black." Other scientists tell
similar tales of research on electromagnetic radiation turning top secret
once successful results were achieved. There are clues that such work is
continuing. In 1995, the annual meeting of four-star U.S. Air Force
generals--called CORONA--reviewed more than 1,000 potential projects. One
was called "Put the Enemy to Sleep/Keep the Enemy From Sleeping." It called
for exploring "acoustics," "microwaves," and "brain-wave manipulation" to
alter sleep patterns. It was one of only three projects approved for initial
investigation.
Direct contact
As the military continues its search for nonlethal weapons,
one device that works on contact has already hit the streets. It is called
the "Pulse Wave Myotron." A sales video shows it in action. A big,
thuggish-looking "criminal" approaches a well-dressed woman. As he tries to
choke her, she touches him with a white device about the size of a pack of
cigarettes. He falls to the floor in a fetal position, seemingly paralyzed
but with eyes open, and he does not recover for minutes.
"Contact with the
Myotron," says the narrator, "feels like millions of tiny needles are sent
racing through the body. This is a result of scrambling the signals from the
motor cortex region of the brain," he says. "It is horrible," says William
Gunby, CEO of the company that developed the Myotron. "It is no toy." The
Myotron overrides voluntary--but not involuntary--muscle movements, so the
victim's vital functions are maintained. Sales are targeted at women, but
law enforcement officers and agencies--including the Arizona state police
and bailiffs with the New York Supreme Court--have purchased the device,
Gunby says. A special model built for law enforcement, called the Black
Widow, is being tested by the FBI, he says. "I hope they don't order a lot
soon," he adds. "The Russian government just ordered 100,000 of them, and I
need to replenish my stock."
The U.S. military also has shown interest in
the Myotron. "About the time of the gulf war, I got calls from people in the
military," recalls Gunby. "They asked me about bonding the Myotron's pulse
wave to a laser beam so that everyone in the path of the laser would
collapse." While it could not be done, Gunby says, he nonetheless was warned
to keep quiet. "I was told that these calls were totally confidential," he
says, "and that they would completely deny it if I ever mentioned it."
Some
say such secrecy is necessary in new-weapons development. But others think
it is a mistake. "Because the programs are secret, the sponsorship is low
level, and the technology is unconventional," says William Arkin of Human
Rights Watch Arms Project, "the military has not done any of the things to
determine if the money is being well spent or the programs are a good idea."
It should not be long before the evidence is in.
LASERS!
Light beams affect mind and body Lasers emit a
high-intensity light, which can force an individual to turn away or cause
blinding. Those that result in permanent blinding have been banned by
international treaty. But dazzling lasers might be used in hostage
situations, prison riots, and special operations. Status: Prototypes exist
Dazzling effects Lasers can force the pupil to close, or they can burn the
light-sensitive retina or cornea depending on the intensity of the beam.
Laser guns Lasers have been developed to be mounted on existing weapons,
such as the M-16 rifle. [labels] Grenade-shell laser Clip-on targeting
transmitter Cornea Pupil Lens Retina
ACOUSTIC WEAPONS!
Arms for crowd control and invisible fencing Acoustic
frequencies could be used to guard sensitive facilities, rescue hostages,
clear paths for military convoys, disperse crowds, or target individuals.
Status: Prototypes exist. [labels] Acoustic frequencies can penetrate
buildings Acoustic "gun" mounted on humvee Sonic "speakers"
Acoustic fencing An array of acoustic devices can keep people away. The
closer they get, the worse they feel. Acoustic effects on the body Sonic
frequencies can cause tiny hair cells in the inner ear to vibrate, creating
sensations like motion sickness, vertigo, and nausea. They can also resonate
internal organs resulting in pain, spasms, or even death.
VORTEX WEAPONS!
These arms can knock down people or even aircraft The vortex
gun expels a doughnut-shaped shock wave that could knock people down. The
gun could also be filled with gases or chemical agents. A vortex ring of
pepper spray, for instance, would stun its victims with both a physical blow
and a chemical irritant. Status: Prototypes exist. They may be hand held or
vehicle mounted Explosive charge creates vortex in shock tube The vortex
ring would travel at hundreds of miles per hour The vortex ring must spin at
Mach 1 or faster to create shock wave Shock wave hits body
SMACK!(r)MDSU¯(r)MDNM¯ They may also contain chemical agents such as pepper
spray.
Vortex technology The vortex gun fires a doughnut-shaped wave with a
powerful center. Lab tests show vortexes can break wooden boards across a
room. When they strike a person, the effect is like being hit with a heavy
blanket.
MICROWAVE WEAPONS!
A "tunable" weapon that can discomfort or cook the enemy As antipersonnel weapons, microwaves could be used as "barriers," causing
pain or burns to those who enter their path. Phaserlike microwave "stun
guns" have also been contemplated, but major technical hurdles still need to
be overcome before their successful development. Status: Research is
classified. Prototypes reportedly exist and are ready for testing. [labels]
Vehicle-mounted microwave gun Microwave "barrier" BZZZZZZT!!! Disturbs
brainwaves Affects heart rate Causes heat, burns, fevers Seizures or stun
effects Impairs motor function.
Microwave effects on the body Microwaves have a wide range of biological
consequences. A heating effect is produced by excitation of water molecules.
Army experiments with animals in non-weapons programs show that microwave
exposure can lead to memory impairment, cardiac arrest, a "stun" effect, and
evoked body movements.
"Terrifying noise weapons that can rupture organs, inflict
burns, and create bubbles and cavities in human tissue may be just
around the corner, an expert has warned. Acoustic weapons are now so
highly developed that they could make an appearance at any moment,
according to writer William M. Arkin[Human Rights Watch]. ...About
20 US government laboratories and military commands were involved in
acoustic weapons development, contracting with half-a-dozen private
companies. ...one of two leading contractors, Scientific
Applications and Research Associates Inc. (Sara), Huntington Beach,
CA. A high-power weapons would radiate a directed energy beam to
"induce severe incapacitation (and if necessary, lethality), within
a specified/designated area." The intensity could vary from a 90 to
120 decibel low-frequency soundwave "to provide extreme levels of
annoyance and distraction", through 150 to 150 decibels for "strong
physical bodily trauma and damage to tissues', to "shockwave" levels
at more than 170 decibels. At this intensity, an acoustic weapon
could produce "instantaneous blastwave-type trauma" and lethal
effects. Very low frequencies could produce internal hemorrhaging
and spasms while higher frequencies were capable of raising body
temperature and burning tissue. At the top end of the frequency
scale, cavitation effects and bubbles could result as the structure
of human flesh broke down." Arkin[writing in the quarterly journal
Medicine Conflict and Survival]said: "Acoustic weapons could be the
next new major weapons to be deployed based upon 'novel' and
heretofore unapplied physical principles in warfare." Arkin
recommended "the humanitarian community to involve itself in the
assessment and debate..." [on high-power acoustic beam weapons.]
...He suggested that Protocol IV[of the Inhumane Weapons Convention]
might be the starting point for curbing acoustic weapons."Medicine,
Conflict and Survival is a journal of the group International
Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War."
-- von Radowitz.(1997, Dec.7). Acoustic Weapons 'Close to Becoming
Reality'.Press Association Newsfile.Lexis-Nexis.
Nazi technology extended far further than has generally been
acknowledged, in fact to almost unfathomable levels. Yet
conventional historians have absolutely failed to provide an
adequate picture of the technology, and weaponry of the
Third Reich. Was it government intervention, peer scepticism
or just plain intellectual laziness which caused these
historians to stop digging? Henry Stevens takes the story to
the mat, providing a glimpse into German research of those
times relying mostly on the governments own reports. Some
were declassified just or this book. Stevens also uses
direct Nazi sources, summarised and translated in this book.
Now we know what spooked the Allies in the closing months of
World War II and why they were in such a panic to win
quickly - they had assembled mind-blowing intelligence
reports of Nazi development of supermetals, electric guns,
and ray weapons that could stop the engines of Allied
aircraft - in addition to highly feared X-ray and laser
weaponry. Then there were the bombs. Contained in this book
are reports of structured bombs of nipolit, N-stoff bombs,
cold bombs, oxygen bombs which could destroy all life,
atomic bombs and rumours of the mysterious molecular bomb.
The true history of the fuel-air bomb is revealed by our own
military. There is even a probability that the SS black
alchemists of the Third Reich were experimenting with red
mercury bomb technology. Very exotic technologies are also
discussed including German experiments in time, Very fusion
reactions, zero point energy and travel in deep space. The
reasons for the scientific flowering in Germany during this
period are discussed in terms of a completely different
scientific paradigm shared by these scientists and how it
relates to a unified view of gravity, matter and energy.
Weapons is one of the bestselling
books on armament ever published. This definitive guide
covers the entire history of weapons, from the earliest,
most primitive instruments up to remarkable advances in
modern defense and warfare. The new edition includes weapons
used in Kosovo, Afghanistan, Iraq and the Israel-Lebanon
conflict, such as:
Improvised Explosive Devices
Blackout bombs
Unmanned aerial vehicles
TV guided bombs
Current Small Arms
Electric Stun Guns
And more!
Comprehensively illustrated, with
hundreds of color diagrams, charts, photographs and much
more, Weapons is the encyclopedia of virtually every arsenal
ever invented. This guide will appeal to warfare fans,
military and history buffs and any reader interested in the
invention, development and use of weapons over the course of
human history.
Scientific
American
This magazine is designed for
technically educated professionals and managers interested
in a broad range of the physical and social sciences.
Its articles and features anticipate what the
breakthroughs and the news will be in a society
increasingly dependent upon scientific and technological
advances.
National Geographic
NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC, the
flagship magazine of the National Geographic Society,
chronicles exploration and adventure, as well as changes
that impact life on Earth. Editorial coverage encompasses
people and places of the world, with an emphasis on human
involvement in a changing universe. Major topics include
culture, nature, geography, ecology, science and
technology.
Popular Mechanics
Popular Mechanics is for people
who have a passion to know how things work. It's about how
the latest advances in science and technology will impact
your home, your car, consumer electronics, computers, even
your health. Popular Mechanics - answers for curious
minds.
Hi-Tech weapons have been a
dream of military for years.
Laser, Microwave, Acoustic, Vortex, Electromagnetic, Pulse, High
Power Microwave (HPM), nonlethal weapons.